• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Health Writer Hub

Health Writer Hub

Medical Writing Courses & Certification

  • COURSES
    • INTRODUCTION TO HEALTH WRITING
    • PRINCIPLES OF HEALTH & MEDICAL COPYWRITING
    • HOW TO CREATE A MEDICAL WRITING PORTFOLIO
    • COURSE BUNDLE
    • VIEW ALL
  • BUNDLE
  • MASTERCLASS
  • BLOG
  • REVIEWS
  • ABOUT
    • TOOLS
    • CPD
    • CONTACT

Fish oil and prostate cancer: research results

When a hot topic breaks in health, you can expect to read about it in every media outlet under the sun.

LAST UPDATED: August 29, 2023 | AUTHOR: Michelle Guillemard

When a hot topic breaks in health, you can expect to read about it in every media outlet under the sun – enter fish oil and prostate cancer.

The problems arise when the ‘hook’ is based on the results of a clinical paper. And we’ve recently witnessed some of these problems in the world of omega-3 fatty acids.

The study that caught everyone’s attention examined associations between plasma phospholipid fatty acids and prostate cancer risk among participants in the Selenium and Vitamin E Cancer Prevention Trial.

Researchers suggested an increased prostate cancer risk among men with high blood concentrations of long chain omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids.

Fish oil and prostate cancer – study results

First, a little disclaimer: I’m not writing this blog to defend or oppose the outcome. If you’re interested, Examine.com have written thorough responses to this study which refute the claims in detail.

My issue is with the media.

This study looked at levels of omega-3 in the blood.

There was no data on whether the men took fish oil supplements or ate fatty fish.

We don’t know how many – if any – took supplements. Nor do we know which other confounding factors may have contributed to the increased risk.

To accurately report this study would be to state that the results suggest an association between higher plasma levels of omega-3 fatty acids and those whom the researchers advise had an increased rate of prostate cancer.

But that doesn’t exactly sound sexy, does it?

Not exactly the kind of headline you’d want to click on, is it?

COURSE OUTLINE: IHW: LOCATION: BLOG POSTS
Enter your email for a free course outline.

Want to enhance your health writing skills?

Our flagship course, Introduction to Health Writing, will teach you how to write health news, features, patient handouts, web content and sales copy.

You'll also get personalised feedback on six weekly health writing tasks plus tons of bonus lessons and extra content.

Enter your email for a free course outline!

You'll also join 22,000+ others who receive our regular emails. Opt out at any time. View our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Loading

The media hype on fish oil and prostate cancer 

It wasn’t surprising that the media didn’t take the high road when this story broke.

The evening news, most papers, and news websites were quick to report that taking fish oil supplements increases prostate cancer risk by 71%.

I followed this issue with interest in the first 72 hours, and here’s a little sample of the fish oil and prostate cancer headlines I collected:

  • Fish oil supplements increase prostate cancer risk, says study – this story wins the award for choosing sensationalism over fact, and unfortunately it’s the one article I’ve seen the most, as it’s been syndicated across many national newspapers. (SMH)
  • Fish oil supplements may raise prostate cancer risk – while I like the use of the word “may”, the writer has used fish oil supplements in the headline which is misleading (Fiji News)
  • Supplements link to prostate cancer confirmed – supplements link confirmed? Where? (The Australian)
  • Taking omega-3 fish oil supplements may increase the risk of aggressive prostate cancer by 70% – falsely implying the risk is associated with fish oil supplements. (Daily Mail)
  • Now they tell us – high omega-3 fatty acids levels increase risk of prostate cancer – “now they tell us?” (Labonline.com.au)
  • Omega-3 supplements ‘could raise prostate cancer risk’ – fair enough with the inverted commas (Telegraph)

I did read balanced, accurate reports on Medical Observer and Ninemsn. SBS also ran a piece with the headline “Study indicates Omega 3 health risks” – so it wasn’t all bad.

You can’t make assumptions in health reporting

While the study didn’t explicitly mention fish oil supplements or dietary intake of fish, these men were clearly getting their omega-3s somehow.

Many of us would assume they were taking supplements. However, we don’t know, so we can’t make assumptions.

There is no evidence that anyone in this study took fish oil supplements, so writers shouldn’t be claiming or implying that supplements cause an increased prostate cancer risk.

All we should report, to be fair, is exactly what the study found: High levels of omega-3s in the blood may be associated with an increased risk in prostate cancer.

Does that mean men concerned about their prostate cancer risk should stop taking fish oil supplements cut out fatty fish from their diets?

Herein lies the problem with research: One study can’t answer that level of detail.

However, there are ways to mention fish oil supplements without directly associating them with the study outcomes. For example, a writer could find a medical expert willing to offer a quote that this study does mean you should stop taking your fish oil supplements.

Health writers should always refer to the original paper

As health writers, we have a responsibility to refer to the original research paper, read it, and determine that we’ve reported on the outcomes accurately.

If we feel we don’t have the skills or understanding to do this (ie if the outcome is too technical or complex for our understanding) we should work with researchers or experts who can help us translate the facts.

Whether due to inexperience, laziness or third party sub-editing, messages do get lost in translation. In these situations, Chinese whispers occurs. And we have a whole population of men concerned about fish oil and prostate cancer risk, returning their fish oil supplements.

Have you read any inaccurate research reports in the media lately?

Print this page

Filed Under: Health writing

About Michelle Guillemard

Michelle Guillemard is the founder of Health Writer Hub, the Past President of the Australasian Medical Writers Association and a freelance medical writer. Blogging about health & medical writing since 2012, Michelle teaches health writing courses and workshops to students and corporations around the world. Michelle is passionate about creating better health outcomes and changing lives through effective health communication. Connect with her on LinkedIn.

 
health copywriting course

Health Writing Template Package

My Health Writing Template Package contains 30+ templates to get you writing high-quality, professional health content.

VIEW DETAILS
health copywriting course

110 Websites That Accept Health Article Pitches for Writers

Gain access to a curated list of 110 trusted health publications actively seeking fresh content. Each entry includes the publication’s focus and submission guidelines, ensuring you’re prepared to make a lasting impression.

VIEW DETAILS

Primary Sidebar

About Michelle Guillemard

Michelle Guillemard is the founder of Health Writer Hub and a seasoned health & medical writer with 20 years of experience. She has taught thousands of writers across 50+ countries, empowering them to create high-quality health content that drives behaviour change and improves public health. As an advocate for AI in health writing, Michelle helps writers stay productive and future-proof their skills.

VIEW MORE

health career guide

The Health & Medical Writing Career Kickstart Guide

Your roadmap to a flexible, fulfilling and financially rewarding writing career

VIEW DETAILS
health copywriting course

Health Writing Template Package

My Health Writing Template Package contains 30+ templates to get you writing high-quality, professional health content.

VIEW DETAILS
health copywriting course

110 Websites That Accept Health Article Pitches for Writers

Gain access to a curated list of 110 trusted health publications actively seeking fresh content. Each entry includes the publication’s focus and submission guidelines, ensuring you’re prepared to make a lasting impression.

VIEW DETAILS
health writing course

How to Write Patient Education Materials

Create compelling healthcare copy for health & medical brands and businesses. Learn an evidence-based approach to persuasive writing and gain exclusive industry insights.

VIEW DETAILS

MOST POPULAR



How to find freelance medical writing work

How to find an entry-level medical writing job

How to build your health writing portfolio

How to write a winning article pitch


EXPLORE TOPICS



Building a medical writing portfolio

Freelance health & medical writing

Getting started in health writing

Health & medical copywriting

Health & medical editing

Health writing

Medical writing and AI

Patient education

Get a personalised course recommendation. Take the 2-minute quiz to find your perfect medical writing course.

GET YOUR COURSE RECOMMENDATION

Footer

Get the latest health writing advice and course news.

Opt out at any time.

SUPPORT

Contact
FAQ
Payment
Disclaimer
Terms
Refunds

ABOUT

About
Reviews
CPD and accreditation
Subscribe

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Courses

Health communication courses for health professionals
Freelance writing
Medical copywriting
Medical editing
Breaking into health writing
View all courses

Health Writer Hub © 2025. All Rights Reserved. I acknowledge the Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the first inhabitants of the nation and the traditional custodians of the lands where I live, learn and work.