• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
Health Writer Hub

Health Writer Hub

Medical Writing Courses & Certification

  • Writing Courses
    • Free Course
    • Breaking Into Health Writing
    • Introduction to Health Writing
    • Principles of Health & Medical Copywriting
    • Freelance Writing Course
    • How to Write Patient Education Materials
    • Medical Editing Course
    • Build Your Portfolio Masterclass
  • Tools
    • Health Writing Template Package
    • Freelance Health Writer Business Planner
    • Article Pitching Guide
  • Blog
  • Reviews
  • About
    • Accreditation
    • Contact
    • Subscribe

Magazine article ideas rejected by an editor? Don’t panic

When an editor knocks back your magazine article ideas, it’s hard not to take this rejection personally.

LAST UPDATED June 16, 2021 | FIRST PUBLISHED March 11, 2014 | BY Michelle Guillemard

LinkedInFacebookTweetPinPrintEmail

When an editor knocks back your magazine article ideas, it’s hard not to take this rejection personally. Usually, there’s a clear reason why your pitch wasn’t successful. Being able to take the emotion out of the equation and regain your writing confidence will ensure that you are 100% clear on what this reason is.

Remember, as I always say, being a writer is all about constant learning. Even if you’re an experienced writer you can still have your magazine article pitches rejected by your editors. If you let rejection get you down, you’re only hurting yourself in the long run.

If you can find it in you to take something positive from the negative, you’ll be a better writer for it and you’ll have more chance of pitching successful ideas in the future.

1. Study the editor’s feedback on your article idea

If an editor has taken the time to respond to you about your magazine article ideas, he or she has probably told you why you’ve been unsuccessful. Was your pitch too boring, too unadventurous, or too similar to what’s already out there? Understand the reasons why your idea was a no-go and follow up with your editor if you need further explanation.

2. Keep it amicable

Don’t let emotion or stress come into your response when you’re communicating with your editor. Yes, it’s tempting to write back a fiery response, but this only looks bad on you. Remember, the fact that your idea wasn’t pursued isn’t a personal attack on your ability. Editors see dozens of pitches every week, and yours could be number fifteen in a long list of fifty or more.

3. Look at the content the magazine publishes for new article ideas

Perhaps your pitch wasn’t quite right for the publication’s target audience. Maybe it wasn’t in the ideal tone, voice or editorial style. Perhaps you need to look for other magazines that accept freelance submissions. Have a read of the most recent pieces on the publication’s website and look at elements like length, headlines, use of health experts, images and quotes. Be sure to look at recent content: pieces from a long time ago may not reflect any new editorial changes in staff, style or policy.

IHW course outline blog post opt in - updated design from 11/1/2023
Enter your email for a free course outline.

Want to learn more about health writing?

Introduction to Health Writing Course

Enhance your health writing skills.

Learn how to write health news, feature articles, web content and blogs.

Enter your email for a free course outline!

You'll also join 20,000+ others who receive our regular emails. Opt out at any time. View our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Loading

4. Consider who else is writing for the publication

Find some other writers who have had published work for the publication you pitched for. Do these writers have the experience you don’t have, in clinical areas or otherwise? You could consider connecting with them on LinkedIn and Twitter to pick up tips and advice to help you out next time you pitch. Some writers will even offer advice, but don’t be disheartened if they don’t: writers are busy people, as you know!

5. Pitch your magazine article ideas again

Don’t give up. Writing is not something that anyone perfects, ever. We all have good days and bad days, as well as great ideas and mediocre ones. Idea generation is tough, and in today’s crowded content market it’s exceptionally hard to pitch unique ideas without feeling like you’re ripping off someone else’s content. Hang in there, keep at it and raise the bar – hard work always pays off in the long run.

Have you had a magazine article idea pitch turned down? How did you manage your next steps?

LinkedInFacebookTweetPinPrintEmail

Filed Under: Getting started as a health writer, Health writing

About Michelle Guillemard

Michelle Guillemard is the founder of Health Writer Hub, the Past President of the Australasian Medical Writers Association and a freelance medical writer. Blogging about health & medical writing since 2012, Michelle teaches health writing courses and communication workshops to students and corporations around the world. Michelle is passionate about creating better health outcomes and changing lives through effective health communication. Connect with her on Instagram, LinkedIn and Facebook.

New to health writing?

Our Breaking Into Health Writing course is the perfect starting point for beginner health writers. You'll explore career options, essential skills, writing styles, in-demand niches, networking, marketing and payment options. After you complete this course, you'll be ready to plan your career transition.

LEARN MORE

Health writing courses

Not sure which course is right for you?

Get in touch, and let's have a chat about your skills and experience.

HELP ME CHOOSE

Footer

Join 20,000+ writers who are learning now. Get the latest health writing advice and course news.

Opt out at any time.

SUPPORT

Contact
FAQ
Payment
Disclaimer
Terms
Refunds

ABOUT

About us
Student feedback
Alumni
Accreditation
Subscribe

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Courses

Health writing
Freelancing
Medical copywriting
Medical editing
Health marketing
Career course
View all courses

Health Writer Hub © 2023. All Rights Reserved. I acknowledge the Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the first inhabitants of the nation and the traditional custodians of the lands where I live, learn and work.

Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

Email sent!