• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Health Writer Hub

Health Writer Hub

Medical Writing Courses & Certification

  • COURSES
    • INTRODUCTION TO HEALTH WRITING
    • PRINCIPLES OF HEALTH & MEDICAL COPYWRITING
    • HOW TO CREATE A MEDICAL WRITING PORTFOLIO
    • COURSE BUNDLE
    • VIEW ALL
  • BUNDLE
  • MASTERCLASS
  • BLOG
  • REVIEWS
  • ABOUT
    • TOOLS
    • CPD
    • CONTACT

Fear-mongering in the media: does it work?

Fear mongering and scare tactics are used in public health campaigns to drive behavioural changes. We see fear in headlines for online articles, food label warnings, pamphlets and brochures. But how effective are these fear-based messages?

LAST UPDATED: October 4, 2024 | AUTHOR: Michelle Guillemard

Fear mongering in the media is common, and public health campaigns use scare tactics to drive behavioural changes.

We see fear mongering in the media for online articles, food label warnings, pamphlets and brochures.

But how effective are these fear-based messages?

In our blog, we recently discussed how fear-based messages tohelp people quit smoking didn’t seem to work.

In fact, feelings of fear alone did not always correlate to quitting smoking.

Still, let’s not dismiss fear altogether. One technique that has shown promise in recent health communication research is combining fear-based messages with another type of emotional message.

Fear mongering in the media works when combined with messages of hopefear mongering in the media

Recent research, published in the journal Health Communication, found consistent evidence from two previously unpublished data sets that suggest fear mongering in the media combined with a message of hope influenced perceptions of sun safety. [1]

In this new study, US researchers found that, for fear to effectively change behaviours, it associates with the different emotional experience of hope. This concept is known as “fear-hope”.

The findings also build on the notion that positive hopeful emotions are helpful in preventative health.

What is “fear-hope”?

The researchers used the concept of “fear-hope” to describe the emotional response that persuaded participants to adopt better sun safe habits.

When threatening information is followed by meaningful use of hope, this creates an emotional drive associated with a greater motivation to change habits.

Both data sets in the research demonstrated feelings of fear facilitated by feelings of hope.

This feeling of “fear-hope” was associated with sun safety intentions and behaviour, but not attitudes.

This included preventative notions to protect against skin cancer.

Hope and behaviour change

Hope is a source of motivation that orients people toward future goals.

Hope is associated with the desire that drives goal-directed action, especially in the face of adversity.

The US researchers suggest hope consists of five emotional states that influence:

  1. Cognition and evaluation of a scenario
  2. Arousal
  3. Feeling subjective
  4. Motivation
  5. Motor expression

By using these emotional responses of hope following the use of fear mongering in the media and health communication, the researchers suggest that, even with negative attitudes, a person can still feel motivated for the desired outcome – such as the onerous task of applying sunscreen.

Want to enhance your health writing skills?

Our flagship course, Introduction to Health Writing, will teach you how to write health news, features, patient handouts, web content and sales copy.

You'll also get personalised feedback on six weekly health writing tasks plus tons of bonus lessons and extra content.

Enter your email for a free course outline!

You'll also join 22,000+ others who receive our regular emails. Opt out at any time. View our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Loading

Fear mongering in the media – responses

The researchers used unpublished data from two different studies to investigate responses to fear and hope from online health messages in the context of sun safety.

Both data sets were based on different samples of the population.

However, the datasets showed significant interactions of hope to predict intentions to change sun safety behaviours.

In the first data set, 341 users viewed a mock WebMD webpage featuring an interview with a chief of skin cancer research expert from the National Cancer Institute.

The information on the page was threatening, such as bolded subsections “How severe is skin cancer!” and “How susceptible are most of us to skin cancer?”

The participants aged 17 to 72 years used Likert scales were then asked to report their response to motivating sun protection statements.

Hope played a small but meaningful role in predicting the intentions to engage in sun safety behaviours – whereas fear alone did not.

Dataset two was based on the same topic of sun safety with a different message.

The participants were a majority female population of 382 undergraduate students aged 18 to 26.

Melanoma awareness YouTube videos were used to assess reactions to the health messages and sun safety behaviours.

Again, participants completed follow-up online questionnaires and Likert scales to indicate their personal relevance of skin cancer, and if they had engaged in a variety of sun safety behaviours following the lab session.

Descriptive analyses found participants experienced both moderate levels of fear and hope after viewing the video.

Why are these fear mongering findings important for health writers?

The researchers’ suggestion that hope emerges as a relevant variable with fear mongering is unsurprising.

The finding confirms fear appeal messages naturally lend themselves to hope evocation.

The findings in the data studied supports how positive and negative emotional responses can work harmoniously to persuade our audience.

Fear can still play a role in our writing, and the researchers still encourage using fear mongering in the media and health communication.

But they suggest if you do, to encourage your audience to feel that engaging in the recommended behaviour will lead to the desired outcome.

Hope can be used to help our readers feel.

Hope is evoked in response to information that relays to a person’s confidence in performing a desired behaviour.

The value of hope for its persuasive effects on fear messages in preventative health is enough for us to integrate carefully in our writing.

Print this page

Filed Under: Health writing

About Michelle Guillemard

Michelle Guillemard is the founder of Health Writer Hub, the Past President of the Australasian Medical Writers Association and a freelance medical writer. Blogging about health & medical writing since 2012, Michelle teaches health writing courses and workshops to students and corporations around the world. Michelle is passionate about creating better health outcomes and changing lives through effective health communication. Connect with her on LinkedIn.

 
health copywriting course

Health Writing Template Package

My Health Writing Template Package contains 30+ templates to get you writing high-quality, professional health content.

VIEW DETAILS
health copywriting course

110 Websites That Accept Health Article Pitches for Writers

Gain access to a curated list of 110 trusted health publications actively seeking fresh content. Each entry includes the publication’s focus and submission guidelines, ensuring you’re prepared to make a lasting impression.

VIEW DETAILS

Primary Sidebar

About Michelle Guillemard

Michelle Guillemard is the founder of Health Writer Hub and a seasoned health & medical writer with 20 years of experience. She has taught thousands of writers across 50+ countries, empowering them to create high-quality health content that drives behaviour change and improves public health. As an advocate for AI in health writing, Michelle helps writers stay productive and future-proof their skills.

VIEW MORE

health career guide

The Health & Medical Writing Career Kickstart Guide

Your roadmap to a flexible, fulfilling and financially rewarding writing career

VIEW DETAILS
health copywriting course

Health Writing Template Package

My Health Writing Template Package contains 30+ templates to get you writing high-quality, professional health content.

VIEW DETAILS
health copywriting course

110 Websites That Accept Health Article Pitches for Writers

Gain access to a curated list of 110 trusted health publications actively seeking fresh content. Each entry includes the publication’s focus and submission guidelines, ensuring you’re prepared to make a lasting impression.

VIEW DETAILS
health writing course

How to Write Patient Education Materials

Create compelling healthcare copy for health & medical brands and businesses. Learn an evidence-based approach to persuasive writing and gain exclusive industry insights.

VIEW DETAILS

MOST POPULAR



How to find freelance medical writing work

How to find an entry-level medical writing job

How to build your health writing portfolio

How to write a winning article pitch


EXPLORE TOPICS



Building a medical writing portfolio

Freelance health & medical writing

Getting started in health writing

Health & medical copywriting

Health & medical editing

Health writing

Medical writing and AI

Patient education

Get a personalised course recommendation. Take the 2-minute quiz to find your perfect medical writing course.

GET YOUR COURSE RECOMMENDATION

Footer

Get the latest health writing advice and course news.

Opt out at any time.

SUPPORT

Contact
FAQ
Payment
Disclaimer
Terms
Refunds

ABOUT

About
Reviews
CPD and accreditation
Subscribe

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Courses

Health communication courses for health professionals
Freelance writing
Medical copywriting
Medical editing
Breaking into health writing
View all courses

Health Writer Hub © 2025. All Rights Reserved. I acknowledge the Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the first inhabitants of the nation and the traditional custodians of the lands where I live, learn and work.