• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Health Writer Hub

Health Writer Hub

Medical Writing Courses & Certification

  • COURSES
    • FREE COURSE
    • HOW TO WRITE PATIENT EDUCATION MATERIALS
    • ADVANCED AI WRITING STRATEGIES
    • HOW TO CREATE A MEDICAL WRITING PORTFOLIO
    • BREAKING INTO HEALTH WRITING
    • HOW TO BECOME A FREELANCE HEALTH WRITER
    • PRINCIPLES OF HEALTH & MEDICAL EDITING
    • INTRODUCTION TO MEDICAL WRITING AND AI
    • INTRODUCTION TO HEALTH WRITING
    • PRINCIPLES OF HEALTH & MEDICAL COPYWRITING
  • BUNDLE & SAVE
  • COURSE FINDER
  • MASTERCLASS
  • TOOLS
  • BLOG
  • ABOUT
    • CPD
    • CONTACT
    • REVIEWS

COVID-19 and the rush to publish: How to find reliable research

As health writers, we have to do our due diligence to ensure we are citing reliable and scientifically accurate sources.

LAST UPDATED: September 26, 2024 | AUTHOR: Hafsa Abdirahman MPH

reliable COVID-19 researchThe COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in an urgent need for scientific research to help us understand the reality of this virus and its toll on humanity. This demand for access to the latest studies has resulted in over 7,000 scientific articles being published in the past three months alone.

Having relevant public health information and access to the latest research can be vital to clinicians, especially in the midst of a pandemic.

The increase in publications creates a treasure trove of resources for us to explore. However, we have to do our due diligence to ensure that we are using reliable and scientifically accurate sources to cite.

Is fast-tracked COVID-19 research reliable?

Many of the recent research articles on COVID-19 aren’t going through the rigorous standards that publishers put in place previously to weed out shoddy science and poor methodology.

Traditionally, prior to publication, researchers had to submit articles to a team of experts who would, ideally, review the science and question the authors about their work. Many of the published COVID-19 papers are not undergoing this process and are instead being released through preprint servers.

To learn more about this issue, I spoke with Dr Ivan Oransky. He’s a physician turned journalist who co-founded Retraction Watch, a blog that keeps track of retracted scientific articles.

“During a pandemic, you can understand why people want studies to get out there more quickly. They want other scientists to build on their results,” he says.

While preprint servers have been around for nearly thirty years, the current main preprint servers for medical and scientific papers, MedRxiv and BioRxiv are relatively new. These servers publish studies that have yet to be peer-reviewed or extensively edited.

Dr Oransk continues: “The risk, of course, is that people don’t see the difference between a preprint and a published paper, because they kind of look the same— at least to an untrained eye. Anyone can publish a preprint without any training.”

This leaves the reader with the responsibility of questioning the science.

COVID-19 retractions

Retraction Watch’s page on COVID-19 retractions lists 15 retractions of papers published so far. The majority of these papers were published in the last two months.

According to Dr Oransky: “On average retractions take about three years. These (seven retractions) are taking days or weeks at most.”

Does this mean that health writers shouldn’t source preprint papers? Not necessarily, as long as the writer notes what kind of paper it is.

“If a manuscript is stated not to have undergone peer review, a health writer should state this when citing the paper,” says Dr Yasmine Ali, Assistant Clinical Professor of Medicine at Vanderbilt University and the President of LastSky Writing, LLC.

Simply put, problematic scientific articles can be found in all publications not just preprint papers.

“Frankly, our experience at Retraction Watch shows that plenty of really dodgy science gets through journals too and gets through peer review. It’s a complex issue,” Dr Oransky states.

The main takeaway is that health writers should remain vigilant in verifying the validity of a source (peer-reviewed or otherwise) before citing it. Here are some tips to help with that.

COURSE OUTLINE: IHW: LOCATION: BLOG POSTS
Enter your email for a free course outline.

Want to enhance your health writing skills?

Our flagship course, Introduction to Health Writing, will teach you how to write health news, features, patient handouts, web content and sales copy.

You'll also get personalised feedback on six weekly health writing tasks plus tons of bonus lessons and extra content.

Enter your email for a free course outline!

You'll also join 22,000+ others who receive our regular emails. Opt out at any time. View our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Loading

Check out the journal

Not all journals are equal. Unfortunately, there are journals that ask authors to pay a fee in order to get published. These predatory journals will publish questionable research and take advantage of readers and authors alike.

Other journals have a vigorous system in place to screen incoming scientific research.

“Look specifically for the manuscripts that are in journals with high impact factors. These are much likelier to be higher-quality research papers due to the integrity of these publications and their internal editing processes,” Dr Ali advises.

She suggests searching for the impact factor on a search engine and to take into consideration that each medical specialty will have its own set of journals.

Some of the examples she gave of high-quality journals are The Lancet, New England Journal of Medicine, British Medical Journal, Nature and Science. “The higher the impact factor, the more reliable the journal,” she says.

Double-check the author’s credentials

Scientists and researchers are required to list all their credentials. Health writers have to take the extra step to look into these author credentials.

This information should be easily available with a simple online search to verify that the authors do have the qualifications listed. There have been cases of unknown or missing authors on questionable research papers.

A quick look at any record of previously retracted papers is also a good idea. Retraction Watch is one resource you can use, but a quick search online can also reveal a lot.

Don’t just read the abstract: analyse the article

Abstracts are meant to summarise the research and hit on the key findings. They are not meant to replace reading the entire article.

Always read the entire article to get a better grasp of the science. When reading through an article, here are some questions you should be asking yourself.

  • Are the methods clearly explained and capable of being reproduced?
  • Are the figures and tables clear and easy to understand?
  • Do they line up with what is written in the results section?
  • Is there a limitations section?
  • Do researchers explain how their results still hold up despite the mentioned limitations?
  • For a clinical study, was there a control group? Or were all participants given the treatment/drug?
  • Are researchers only relying on case reports for their results?

Verify the research with experts

As health writers, we may find ourselves writing about a broad range of topics that are outside of our personal knowledge. We don’t have to know it all, but we do have to ensure that what we write is factual. It’s important to reach out and seek expert opinions.

Find experts in the field and ask them about their thoughts on a specific manuscript.

Don’t feel afraid of appearing unintelligent or asking stupid questions. If something doesn’t make sense to you, there’s a good chance you aren’t the only one who thinks so.

Experts are also clued into their respective academic or scientific communities. They are more likely to know which researchers or scholarly works are problematic or representing a conflict of interest.

Single studies vs bodies of science

It seems every couple of days a new drug or treatment is being touted as effectively treating COVID-19 only to be later refuted by another paper. (Take the recent hydroxychloroquine controversy for example).

“In a perfect world, I would… all together stay away from single papers because more often than not they don’t hold up or they turn out to be an incomplete version of reality,” Dr Oransky says.

Multiple studies finding similar results with a large number of patients hold more weight than a single study showing surprising results. However, it can be argued during a pandemic any study that shows promising results should be shared. It’s relevant and newsworthy.

So, what should a health writer do? Try to focus on the bigger picture. How does this one study compare with the literature? Refer back to the methods used and be sure to include any limitations such as a small number of patients or the lack of a control group.

“It’s much more important to include context and try and report on the state of the science rather than the state of a single study. That’s challenging particularly in the time of a pandemic,” Dr Oransky states.

This post hoped to provide tips for health writers on how to discern whether a published work is a reliable source. In light of all the research being shared with the world at lightning speed, we need to step up as health communicators and do our part in sharing good science and calling out misinformation. We serve an important role in sharing and explaining complicated science to the general public. It’s our responsibility to ensure that the information we are sharing is accurate.

Print this page

Filed Under: Health writing, Patient education

About Hafsa Abdirahman MPH

Hafsa Abdirahman MPH is a public health scientist and freelance medical writer and editor. She believes that access to evidence-based, quality health information can save lives and she’s worked throughout her career to put this belief into practice. You can find her at Health Culturally where she blogs about health issues facing the Somali community. Connect with her on LinkedIn.

Hafsa is a member of the Health Writer Hub Alumni.

 
health copywriting course

Health Writing Template Package

My Health Writing Template Package contains 30+ templates to get you writing high-quality, professional health content.

VIEW DETAILS
health copywriting course

110 Websites That Accept Health Article Pitches for Writers

Gain access to a curated list of 110 trusted health publications actively seeking fresh content. Each entry includes the publication’s focus and submission guidelines, ensuring you’re prepared to make a lasting impression.

VIEW DETAILS

Primary Sidebar

About Michelle Guillemard

Michelle Guillemard is the founder of Health Writer Hub and a seasoned health & medical writer with 20 years of experience. She has taught thousands of writers across 50+ countries, empowering them to create high-quality health content that drives behaviour change and improves public health. As an advocate for AI in health writing, Michelle helps writers stay productive and future-proof their skills.

VIEW MORE

health career guide

The Health & Medical Writing Career Kickstart Guide

Your roadmap to a flexible, fulfilling and financially rewarding writing career

VIEW DETAILS
health copywriting course

Health Writing Template Package

My Health Writing Template Package contains 30+ templates to get you writing high-quality, professional health content.

VIEW DETAILS
health copywriting course

110 Websites That Accept Health Article Pitches for Writers

Gain access to a curated list of 110 trusted health publications actively seeking fresh content. Each entry includes the publication’s focus and submission guidelines, ensuring you’re prepared to make a lasting impression.

VIEW DETAILS
health writing course

How to Write Patient Education Materials

Create compelling healthcare copy for health & medical brands and businesses. Learn an evidence-based approach to persuasive writing and gain exclusive industry insights.

VIEW DETAILS

MOST POPULAR



How to find freelance medical writing work

How to find an entry-level medical writing job

How to build your health writing portfolio

How to write a winning article pitch


EXPLORE TOPICS



Building a medical writing portfolio

Freelance health & medical writing

Getting started in health writing

Health & medical copywriting

Health & medical editing

Health writing

Medical writing and AI

Patient education

Get a personalised course recommendation. Take the 2-minute quiz to find your perfect medical writing course.

GET YOUR COURSE RECOMMENDATION

Footer

Get the latest health writing advice and course news.

Opt out at any time.

SUPPORT

Contact
FAQ
Payment
Disclaimer
Terms
Refunds

ABOUT

About
Reviews
CPD and accreditation
Subscribe

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Courses

Health communication courses for health professionals
Freelance writing
Medical copywriting
Medical editing
Breaking into health writing
View all courses

Health Writer Hub © 2025. All Rights Reserved. I acknowledge the Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the first inhabitants of the nation and the traditional custodians of the lands where I live, learn and work.